• Contact
  • About VozWire
  • Careers
  • Correction Policy
Saturday, February 27, 2021
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
VozWire
  • Home
  • Fact Check
  • World
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Science
  • Tech
    The Lincoln Project now under fire after doxing President Trump’s legal counsel on Twitter

    The Lincoln Project now under fire after doxing President Trump’s legal counsel on Twitter

    Civil Rights org has now teamed up with watchdogs to take President Trump off of Twitter

    Civil Rights org has now teamed up with watchdogs to take President Trump off of Twitter

    Hard core Trump supporters tell they are sick of text spam from GOP

    Big tech squashes Trump 2020 campaign text messaging plan

    Twitter chief Dorsey under major fire after Bitcoin hack hit Obama, Biden & more

    Tech research doc tells that google ‘will shift 10% of voters’ and make Trump a ‘blip in history’

    Trending Tags

    • Sillicon Valley
    • Climate Change
    • Election Results
    • Flat Earth
    • Golden Globes
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Mr. Robot
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Music
    • Sports
    Heavy metal band Iced Earth breaks up after founder is arrested for participating in Capitol riot

    Heavy metal band Iced Earth breaks up after founder is arrested for participating in Capitol riot

    Texas DPS mistakenly sends out Amber Alert email with ‘Chucky’ listed as the suspect

    Texas DPS mistakenly sends out Amber Alert email with ‘Chucky’ listed as the suspect

    Brian Williams pulls off hilarious troll job with “exclusive” video of Trump and McCarthy meeting

    Brian Williams pulls off hilarious troll job with “exclusive” video of Trump and McCarthy meeting

    Barron Trump’s mysterious home life may give us insight into the relationship he has with his father

    Barron Trump’s mysterious home life may give us insight into the relationship he has with his father

    Here’s how our Presidential inauguration plans have changed

    Here’s how our Presidential inauguration plans have changed

    Stand-up comedian John Mulaney says he was investigated by the Secret Service over joke ‘that was not about Donald Trump’

    Stand-up comedian John Mulaney says he was investigated by the Secret Service over joke ‘that was not about Donald Trump’

    Rob Reiner warns that Pres. Donald Trump and family must be prosecuted for ‘survival of our democracy’

    Rob Reiner warns that Pres. Donald Trump and family must be prosecuted for ‘survival of our democracy’

    Reality TV star Claudia Jordan says Donald Trump was only nice to her because he wanted to get with her, accuses him of being a racist

    Reality TV star Claudia Jordan says Donald Trump was only nice to her because he wanted to get with her, accuses him of being a racist

    America just elected its first openly trans state senator, Sarah McBride of Delaware

    Woman that Donald Trump Jr. had affair with says he discussed releasing naked pics to silence her

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • food
    • Health
    • Travel
    Reproductive rights groups work with Biden to assure women’s right to abortion access

    Reproductive rights groups work with Biden to assure women’s right to abortion access

    Pres. Donald Trump’s attorney Jenna Ellis claims that Jesus wants her to reverse election results

    Unbearable heat at Florida Trump rally sends dozens to the hospital, some fainted and had seizures

    Las Vegas therapist performs ‘Trump conversion therapy’, making supporters vote for Joe Biden

    Mitch McConnell denies having health issues despite severe bruising on hands and around lips

    US diplomats and spies have accused the Trump administration of covering up a mysterious illness that affected officials in China, Cuba and Russia

    Joanna Gaines makes surprise announcement and it’s getting fans excited

    First Lady Melania Trump fires back at former pal after tell-all book in September

    First Lady Melania Trump fires back at former pal after tell-all book in September

    Trump suggests Military/Police to blame for infected White House: “They want to hug you, and they want to kiss you”

    Trump suggests Military/Police to blame for infected White House: “They want to hug you, and they want to kiss you”

    After observing Trump’s behavior, UCSF doctor suggests maybe ‘the 25th Amendment should be invoked’

    Trending Tags

    • Golden Globes
    • Mr. Robot
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Climate Change
    • Flat Earth
  • Home
  • Fact Check
  • World
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Science
  • Tech
    The Lincoln Project now under fire after doxing President Trump’s legal counsel on Twitter

    The Lincoln Project now under fire after doxing President Trump’s legal counsel on Twitter

    Civil Rights org has now teamed up with watchdogs to take President Trump off of Twitter

    Civil Rights org has now teamed up with watchdogs to take President Trump off of Twitter

    Hard core Trump supporters tell they are sick of text spam from GOP

    Big tech squashes Trump 2020 campaign text messaging plan

    Twitter chief Dorsey under major fire after Bitcoin hack hit Obama, Biden & more

    Tech research doc tells that google ‘will shift 10% of voters’ and make Trump a ‘blip in history’

    Trending Tags

    • Sillicon Valley
    • Climate Change
    • Election Results
    • Flat Earth
    • Golden Globes
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Mr. Robot
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Music
    • Sports
    Heavy metal band Iced Earth breaks up after founder is arrested for participating in Capitol riot

    Heavy metal band Iced Earth breaks up after founder is arrested for participating in Capitol riot

    Texas DPS mistakenly sends out Amber Alert email with ‘Chucky’ listed as the suspect

    Texas DPS mistakenly sends out Amber Alert email with ‘Chucky’ listed as the suspect

    Brian Williams pulls off hilarious troll job with “exclusive” video of Trump and McCarthy meeting

    Brian Williams pulls off hilarious troll job with “exclusive” video of Trump and McCarthy meeting

    Barron Trump’s mysterious home life may give us insight into the relationship he has with his father

    Barron Trump’s mysterious home life may give us insight into the relationship he has with his father

    Here’s how our Presidential inauguration plans have changed

    Here’s how our Presidential inauguration plans have changed

    Stand-up comedian John Mulaney says he was investigated by the Secret Service over joke ‘that was not about Donald Trump’

    Stand-up comedian John Mulaney says he was investigated by the Secret Service over joke ‘that was not about Donald Trump’

    Rob Reiner warns that Pres. Donald Trump and family must be prosecuted for ‘survival of our democracy’

    Rob Reiner warns that Pres. Donald Trump and family must be prosecuted for ‘survival of our democracy’

    Reality TV star Claudia Jordan says Donald Trump was only nice to her because he wanted to get with her, accuses him of being a racist

    Reality TV star Claudia Jordan says Donald Trump was only nice to her because he wanted to get with her, accuses him of being a racist

    America just elected its first openly trans state senator, Sarah McBride of Delaware

    Woman that Donald Trump Jr. had affair with says he discussed releasing naked pics to silence her

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • food
    • Health
    • Travel
    Reproductive rights groups work with Biden to assure women’s right to abortion access

    Reproductive rights groups work with Biden to assure women’s right to abortion access

    Pres. Donald Trump’s attorney Jenna Ellis claims that Jesus wants her to reverse election results

    Unbearable heat at Florida Trump rally sends dozens to the hospital, some fainted and had seizures

    Las Vegas therapist performs ‘Trump conversion therapy’, making supporters vote for Joe Biden

    Mitch McConnell denies having health issues despite severe bruising on hands and around lips

    US diplomats and spies have accused the Trump administration of covering up a mysterious illness that affected officials in China, Cuba and Russia

    Joanna Gaines makes surprise announcement and it’s getting fans excited

    First Lady Melania Trump fires back at former pal after tell-all book in September

    First Lady Melania Trump fires back at former pal after tell-all book in September

    Trump suggests Military/Police to blame for infected White House: “They want to hug you, and they want to kiss you”

    Trump suggests Military/Police to blame for infected White House: “They want to hug you, and they want to kiss you”

    After observing Trump’s behavior, UCSF doctor suggests maybe ‘the 25th Amendment should be invoked’

    Trending Tags

    • Golden Globes
    • Mr. Robot
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Climate Change
    • Flat Earth
No Result
View All Result
VozWire
No Result
View All Result
Home Politics

Opinion: The EU doesn’t understand how the Internet works – thank goodness we’re leaving

Jason Reed by Jason Reed
March 28, 2019
in Politics
0
206
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The EU has long been synonymous with liberal economics. An entire movement of leftist Euroscepticism is founded on the notion that the Union is harshly capitalistic. Helpfully, the EU has now clarified its position as the purveyor of an interventionist hellscape by introducing the most ludicrous piece of legislation since the Licensing Act of 1872 made it illegal to be drunk while in possession of a cow.

Few should be surprised that the EU, which has no fewer than seven presidents, is a hub of festering bureaucracy. Nonetheless, it continues to break exciting new ground with administrative exercises of exponentially increasing futility, to the point that anyone even thinking about running a business is swamped in enough red tape to wrap all the Christmas presents of every single one of the ten trillion faceless androids who make up its almighty bureaucratic machine.

Sir Humphrey Appleby of the timeless Yes, Minister would be immensely proud of the EU as it stands today. “Governments can only measure their success by the size of their staff and budget,” he declares. “Suppose everybody went around saving money irresponsibly all over the place!” Not only is the EU immune to any measures designed to improve efficiency, but it seems irretrievably in the grip of a brutal jurisdictive addiction which compels it to churn out endless new regulations, governing everyone and everything in sight to within an inch of their lives.

The latest example of this, known as the Copyright Directive, represents state interference at its very worst. An inherently undemocratic, cripplingly unaccountable and wildly inefficient supranational government bungles its way into a thriving industry like a drunk in a bar, bellowing and pointing at disgusted onlookers about how they are living their lives all wrong. It is so amazingly toxic that swathes of lawmakers had to be tricked into approving it through sleazy tactics such as changing the voting order without telling anyone so that members of Parliament voted it through by mistake.

Article 13 has been the subject of intense discussion in recent months. We all foresaw its arrival, but it was so godawful and frankly risible that we subconsciously refused en masse to accept its veracity for some time. As a result, the Creature from the Brussels Black Lagoon caught us by surprise while we were preoccupied with other things. It crept up on us like a mugger in the night, except that this one is wearing an ill-fitting Italian suit and loafers that don’t match, is very clearly drunk and is armed only with a croissant and a rolled-up copy of the Evening Standard.

If there is one good thing about the Copyright Directive, it is that it is mercifully easy to understand. The EU hates progress and loves paperwork; appreciating the driving forces behind legal developments is rarely simpler than that. We live in a bizarre dystopian timeline in which nonsensically technical discussions persistently and violently pry their way into our political discourse, leading us to the ludicrous point where people unironically discuss the merits of different types of customs unions on BBC Radio 5 Live. It is helpful, therefore, when a news story not directly related to that day’s epic Brexit cock-up comes along to concisely remind us of why we are subjecting ourselves to all this.

Article 13 is the EU in a nutshell. It epitomises everything that is wrong with the over-grown, over-blown bloc, all in one handy little take-anywhere package. It represents staggeringly clumsy state intervention in private industry. It fails to take account of even the most basic aspects of how the Internet works, in a manner akin to that of senile US Senators quizzing Mark Zuckerberg on how he makes any profit when Facebook’s services are free to users. And, best of all, unlike murderously complicated Brexit developments, it is a good old-fashioned news story that can be condensed into a headline that is crying out for nuance but is guaranteed to evoke a reaction. EU bans memes! That is the kind of politics people without a PhD in the European constitution can understand.

The main problem with Article 13 is that it is completely unnecessary. It seeks to make it more difficult for copyrighted content to be maliciously used without its owner’s permission. Laws prohibiting exactly that already exist and are in force across Europe. Under the existing laws, if a party believes their content has been used unlawfully, they can sue and win damages. This is a wholly sufficient legal framework; the new reforms are entirely extraneous. Then again, if they cannot spend countless manhours crafting needless new regulation, what is a colossal horde of civil servants bored out of their minds to do?

The Copyright Directive aims to place the burden on the providers of platforms, such as social media companies, by compelling them to implement considerably stricter internal content regulation. This, of course, explains YouTube’s vociferous campaign against the move. Tech companies will find themselves forced to censor content harshly to prevent even the slightest whiff of copyright infringement, in order to avoid legal jeopardy. This, besides anything else, is directly antithetical to fundamental principles of the rule of law.

Trying to legally compel YouTube to pre-emptively ban the upload of content that may or may not infringe copyright law is like trying to force a company that manufactures kitchen equipment to pre-emptively guarantee that its knives will never be used in acts of violence. Such action is not possible and attempts to make it a legal requirement will result only in the stifling of investment and the compromise of consumer rights. It is the clumsiest approach to legislation imaginable.

YouTube, for instance, already uses a highly effective Content ID system which detects, flags up and even blocks copyright-protected content such as music and videos. This policy is in place because it is not in YouTube’s interest to have to fight dozens of new court cases every day over copyright infringement. Article 13 will go one step further – and then about another hundred steps after that – by making it illegal for YouTube to host any copyrighted content whatsoever without express permission from its owner, which in turn will force YouTube to raise its standards markedly, which will have a knock-on effect on users and content creators, as well as the profitability of the company and the viability of further growth and investment in Europe.

We are living through something of a vlogger’s renaissance. Over three hundred hours of content are uploaded to YouTube every minute and, inevitably, much like those Shakespearean monkeys and their typewriters, some of it is worthwhile. Article 13 will put an end to that once and for all; in Europe, at least. It has been reported that some videos containing birdsong or cats purring have been misidentified by the present system as infringing audio copyright; these disadvantages of unavoidably fallible systems will be exacerbated many times over by the cataclysmically irresponsible measures spelled out in Article 13.

This is not a case of a particular clause within a piece of legislation being ill-thought-out and leading to unforeseen consequences; the entire approach to regulation espoused in the Copyright Directive is fundamentally flawed. It is like insisting on the use of sledgehammers to crack nuts, resulting in a cloud of nutty dust and not a single discernible nut. This modus operandi is yet more catastrophic for smaller technology companies such as Patreon, which do not have the disposable funds of Google or Facebook and will struggle to comply with the new rules, resulting inevitably in a blatant hinderance of growth and development.

Unsurprisingly, no other legislative body around the world has shown any sign of considering replicating the EU Copyright Directive in their jurisdiction (which probably has something to do with the fact that European agenda-setters are perhaps the only Western politicians who will not have to face democratic accountability for their decisions, meaning that they needn’t bother with pesky inconveniences like public opinion or common sense). The result is that the Internet will soon become detached from a separate European sub-Internet, which will have its own set of standards and an entirely different approach to regulation and online consumer and creator rights.

This means that citizens of EU countries where Article 13 is implemented will have access to a different version of YouTube, for instance, to everyone else. For those who are not au fait with the use of VPNs, the Internet will essentially no longer extend beyond the borders of Europe. The new measures will also nigh-on eliminate any chance for any technology company that is not already one of the established giants to grow and become a significant player. The Next Big Thing will not come from Europe, because companies here will be competing at a debilitating disadvantage.

Some have claimed that the branding of Article 13 as a ‘meme ban’ is an unfair characterisation. They point forlornly at the vague provisions it makes for undefined categories such as ‘parody’ and ‘pastiche’, which sound impressively non-committal, to the effect that the platforms – which are understandably unattracted to the idea of hauling themselves in front of the European courts on a regular basis over this – will be forced to err on the safe side. In other words, the inevitable consequence of this he-hits-and-he-misses Directive will be that a huge volume of content that breaks no rules whatsoever will be blocked.

Memes might not be completely banned, in the same way that careering a Ferrari head-on into a tree at a hundred miles an hour might not make it disintegrate or cause it to disappear without a trace. But you still won’t be driving it again any time soon.

Jason Reed

Jason Reed

Jason Reed is a VozWire Political Correspondent. He is an undergraduate student at the London School of Economics and Political Science. As a freelance writer, he has contributed comment and analysis articles to various outlets including Conservative Home, Reaction, 1828, Brexit Central and The Conservative Woman. He is Vice President of The London Globalist and Treasurer of the LSE Conservative Society. See also: www.jason-reed.co.uk/about

Next Post

Weekend Take Out: The Mueller Report Could be the Democrat's Undoing

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The Latest

Sen. Lindsey Graham thought Costco CEO would agree with him on no min. wage increase, but it didn’t go as planned

Sen. Lindsey Graham thought Costco CEO would agree with him on no min. wage increase, but it didn’t go as planned

20 hours ago
Lauren Boebert may have violated copyright law when she used a NY business’s photo to taunt Bill Gates

Lauren Boebert hints that she is carrying a gun to Congress in spite of Pelosi’s ‘no gun’s rule’

20 hours ago

Popular News

  • Donald Trump told Sarah Sanders she needed to ‘take one for the team’ after Kim Jong-un winked at her

    Donald Trump told Sarah Sanders she needed to ‘take one for the team’ after Kim Jong-un winked at her

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • FACT CHECK: Social media posts wrongly blame Biden for higher gas prices

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Hotel staff say Donald Trump had absurd requests: needed diet coke opened in front of him, had to hear the pop of the new ketchup bottle being unsealed

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Michael Cohen predicts Trump tax investigation will result in jail time: He should hurry and get a custom-made jumpsuit

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Trump releases angry statement after Supreme Court makes ruling in favor of NY prosecutor on his case

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • About
  • Careers
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Copyright and Fair Use Policy
  • DMCA Policy
  • Correction Policy
Email Us: [email protected]
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Fact Check
  • Correction Policy
  • Politics
  • World
  • Business
  • Science
  • National
  • Entertainment
  • Gaming
  • Movie
  • Music
  • Sports
  • Fashion
  • Lifestyle
  • Travel
  • Tech
  • Health
  • Food

© 2019 VozWire

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In